Popular Posts

Showing posts with label - pic taken from the net. Show all posts
Showing posts with label - pic taken from the net. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

- Philosophy Writing Assignment 2, Due Date, 11/13/09 ...




Freud vs. Plato

Two Ideas of Love & Sex in Society


Both Freud and Plato espouse a concept valuing the roles of love and sex in society. Plato's philosophy taught the Ascent of Love noting the importance of educating, and mentoring youth in matters of love, for instance, the paradox in shame and pride associated with one's sexuality. From this point in the early development of a young person's sexuality, we could expect to see an acceptance of the beauty of one's own body, and eventually an understanding of true beauty in relationship, and the world around them. This could then lead to an understanding, and appreciation for true beauty in all experiences; and eventually a falling in love with knowledge, and wisdom.
Freud's position seems to stand on the suppression of natural, human instinct, or one's drive to further the species. In Freud's argument we see the human animal led, if not cowed into a socially accepted
form of behavior that diametrically opposes ones' natural state of being, that of a sexual being driven to propagate the species. While both positions are, to me, an obvious flattery of the human act of sexuality; I feel it's important to recognize the danger in their underlying suggestion of sexual freedom in ones' youthful, developmental years. It is certainly true, especially with the freedoms available in today's society, that an education, or mentoring of an individual's position as a sexual being is valuable. We must, however, be constantly aware of just how fragile the individual in question may be to such suggestion.
We may take seriously, the opportunity to view the opinion of someone who has been on both sides of this argument. One, who has been inappropriately exposed to their own sexuality at a very tender age, may have some rare insight to this question of sexual suppression, or sexual mentoring. I would contend that some such individual, who has experienced such an act, and come through it, healthier and more well adjusted then most, by way of the experience and subsequent recovery, may very well have exquisite insight to offer. Taken at face value, the idea of sexual freedom and sexual mentoring for the purpose of one's education in matters of love is a radical, if not compassionate idea. Left to the masses, it becomes a tool to be abused, a loving concept twisted for ulterior motives.
In the Symposium we read about love as a technique, a skillful art one is expected to learn. Love between the elder and the younger teaches the delicate balance between shame and pride. We read of love's common lower form, and how the pursuit of love's higher form is enduring, and virtuous leading to moral excellence. In Agathon's speech we read of love's divinity, how love is inspirational and wills us toward excellence and goodness. Finally, in Socrates' discourse with Diotima we learn of the ascent of love:
"The correct way", she said, "for someone to approach this business is to begin when he's young by being drawn towards beautiful bodies. At first, if his guide leads him correctly, he should love just one body and in that relationship produce beautiful discourses. Next he should realize that the beauty of any one body is closely related to that of another, and that, if he is to pursue beauty of form, it's very foolish to regard the beauty of all bodies as one and the same. Once he's seen this, he'll become a lover of all beautiful bodies, and will relax his intense passion for just one body, despising this passion and regarding it as petty. After this, he should regard the beauty of minds as more valuable" … (Plato, 2000)
Freud discusses the dysfunction of sexual suppression in his book Sexual Morality and Modern Nervousness. In these chapters, he argues for the injurious effects of the rising tide of imposed, sexual morality on society. He points out, rather effectively how current society is quite literally inundated by those things around us, and his writing in this area is remarkably transferrable to today's lifestyle, what with the forms of media and entertainment we are subject to. He shows, by way of example, the affect this phenomenon has on individuals and the resulting neurosis. In any case, the lack of education, suppressed urge or desire, and/or suppression of knowledge inevitably lead to some resulting negative behavior. Undoubtedly, this is illuminating reading for one who has experienced any of these behaviors:
"Clearly, education does not look lightly on the task of suppressing the sensuality of the girl until marriage, for it employs the most drastic measures. It not only forbids sexual intercourse and sets a high premium upon the preservation of sexual chastity, but it also protects the developing young woman from temptation by keeping her in ignorance of all the facts concerning the part she is ordained to play, and tolerates in her no love-impulse which cannot lead to marriage. The result is that when the girl is suddenly allowed by parental authority to fall in love, she cannot accomplish this mental operation and enters the state of marriage uncertain of her own feelings", … "When later the retarded development of the wife becomes rectified, and during the climax of her womanly life the full power to love awakens in her, her relation to her husband has been long undermined. As a reward for her previous submission, there remains for her only the choice between unappeased desire, infidelity, or neurosis". (Freud, 1938)
I quite willingly accept both positions as valuable. First the idea that a suppressed sexual desire will undoubtedly lead to distorted ideas of love and relationship, and ultimately neurotic, if not deviant sexual behaviors. Second, the notion that it is imperative to educate an individual, however youthful, of their position as a sexual being, and the healthy ability we each possess to embrace this part of ourselves; as well the value in this education to lead us toward wholesome, loving relationships. Simply put, experience leads me to caution. As a husband and father of four, ages eleven to twenty, I see value in education. I also see education, tempered with a healthy dose of reality as essential.
If I may paraphrase a classmate: during lecture she (nameless) noted that in her opinion it was rather healthy to enjoy a lifestyle where she entertained multiple partners, in an effort to meet her need for sexual fulfillment. Her gratification was the ultimate, end all, be all goal of this endeavor, she was quite happy to live her life thus. On the surface, one might think she was a well adjusted young woman, healthy enough to speak her mind, and take a stand on a rather contentious topic. I would certainly hope that she is prepared for the inevitable consequences that arise from this lifestyle. Here I would argue for Plato's Ascent of Love. In this formula, a guarded, healthy education allows for the understanding of love for one's own body, a sense of absolute respect for one's self. Subsequently we learn to find love in oneother; from this position we stand to learn love of humanity in all its forms, and love of the mind (person) as an individual. This speaks to me of a learned respect and appreciation for ones' self and the dignity of others in an enduring quest for personal growth and knowledge, if that doesn't sing of Love in its purest sense, truly, I ask, what does?

- Submitted for your consideration, for those who know, the purge was done, Long Ago !!!

- Love, S

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

- More Writing Assignments ...


- what follows is an assignment handed in, Wednesday; 10/14/09

both posts, from yesterday (10/13/09), and today are expamples

of the work I've been doing for school, not meant to be fun reading

by any stretch of the imagination, hope it's at least, "me' ...




Polytheistic vs. Monotheistic


An Opinion of the Hindu Religious Tradition


Is Hinduism polytheistic or monotheistic? I don’t know that that there is a short answer to this question. While it is certainly true that I have a great deal to learn about the Hindu tradition, the few short chapters we have studied thus far lead me to believe that this Religious Tradition, and it’s rituals are as vast as those people that practice it. Something that jumps out at me is the idea of one person as the representative of an entire faith, dictating theology, and making finite decisions that govern practice & worship tradition. In my opinion, this is the very point that makes the Hindu Tradition as rich and varied as it has become. The tradition has survived with no one individual, wholly in governance over it. As various, and sundry are the needs of its people, so have become the distinctives that define it as a Religion.

In The Rig Veda we’ve met Agni, Indra, Soma, Vishnu, and Rudra, just to name a few. These are Gods of fire and sacrifice, The King of the Gods, Gods of asceticism and minor Gods who at the very least, are relatives at best! When trying to answer the question, one might be tempted to look to this part of Hinduism’s history and refer to the Gods of the Rig Veda, as the end all, be all answer. I think this would amount to selling this vast tradition short. From the Upanishads we learn of the law of Karma, Reincarnation, and that the cycle of birth, death and re-birth is to be regarded as some sort of tortuous existence. The Laws of Manu give us a path to follow, that eventually lead to a oneness with Brahman, or the Truth. In the Epics we see the Gods coming to the rescue of earth bound creatures, saving us from ourselves, and our fallen humanity. Through the Puranic texts, the Gods Visnu, Shiva and Brahma take on a hierarchy, and whether you follow Shiva or Visnu, by this time one of them is in charge of it all.

My own experience leads me to compare this tradition with the one that I know best, Christianity. In my forty years, I’ve had some very difficult dealings with organized Religious Tradition, and have come to regard much of it as corrupt in every way. To see something as free to interpretation, as The Hindu Tradition seems to be, is refreshing to say the least. In The Christian Tradition we have a monotheistic faith that recognizes God in three forms, “The Holy Trinity”. Yet one could argue that the Catholic Christians’ have raised Christ’s mother Mary to the level of deity, or that the “Saints”, as appointed by the Vatican, are raised to the level of deity. Good grief, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention those childhood memories where I witnessed members of my parish praying at the feet of a statue of Joseph, so much for no Idol worship!

In any light, if the Christian Tradition is monotheistic, by definition, then how can I, as a lifelong practitioner of this faith, in one form or the other, recognize the Hindu Tradition as anything less? Conversely, having witnessed the practices of those Christians I’ve seen, over forty years, how do I define one tradition as polytheistic and not the other? Hopefully I’ve not led you too far off course, and by this point you can see my dilemma. To answer the question I would have to refer back to my original point, that being the people who practice Hinduism as a tradition. Thus the question is posed, is Hinduism polytheistic or monotheistic? Through its history, it seems that there has always been one truth. Be it Indra, the King of the Gods, defeating Vrtra and freeing the waters, or the omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent Brahman. This one truth stays consistent throughout.

In this same way, it seems that each individual journey is one that leads to this same, cosmic, individual truth; therefore I would have to surmise that, while the number and history of the God’s in Hinduism would suggest a polytheistic tradition, it seems more likely that a monotheistic journey in faith is likely here. I arrive at this conclusion simply by recognizing that no one experience seems to be taken lightly. As was pointed out in lecture; there was no one person correcting the version of any given idea, or interpretation. Each new addition to the experience was accepted and eventually added to the tapestry. As problems arose, solutions were offered and accepted, as valuable. Whether you worship, Visnu, Shiva, Brahma, or a combination of the three, it seems like Brahman is the destination. I feel that if we’re looking for an answer to a monotheistic or polytheistic question, we need look no further than the Abrahamic Faiths of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. If a commonality links these three, than certainly, there is a commonality in the vast root system of the Hindu Tradition.



- if you made it this far, Thanks !!!

- Love, S.

- A Little More About, "Who Am I? ...

- All my other stuff ...